Apparently it is a common phenomena for us to hear a recording of our voices or music and think, “that doesn’t sound like me!” I have had that feeling whenever I tried to record myself playing music and became somewhat phobic toward recording.
I got to the point that whenever I would try to record myself I would become instantly self conscious about how I thought the recording was going to sound. Not only that, my imagined listener was the equivalent of a sold out audience at Carnegie Hall. So, hitting ‘Record’ on the device was triggered self conscious imaginings of performance that weren’t even in my realm of experience. I wasn’t imagining a poor performance in a coffee shop or busking in a transit station. I was imagining a poor performance in a venue and for an audience that I had never encountered. The result was that I became avoidant of recording.
At the same time, I have not played music for many years, all during the intensity of a decade of graduate work. Now that I have graduated and my life is reforming back to some semblance of ‘normal’ I am experiencing these musical stirrings. It is deep and mysterious, amorphous, except when I tell myself, “That is it!” I am starting in a new place, a place that conforms my musical practice to something that I have never done before.
First, I no longer labor under the illusions that my music is going to achieve Adele-level adulation. It is not. Second, I am noticing that when I make music, in many different forms, my brain feels different from before I start and when I finish a music making session. I enjoy how my brain changes. There is also a wider physiological experience with music making. My entire body feels different, in a good way. Third, as I enter my 70th decade (!) I am turning 60 next month, I have creative impulses that reveal themselves to me through practice, that is, not practicing scales and chords, or improving finger dexterity, but, rather, sitting down with an instrument in hand and noticing where it leads me.
My current music-making situation is this: I am not seeking a professional career and I am not pursuing a disciplined approach to music expression. Playing music is about experiencing music in the same way I follow a new trail in the mountains. I am walking at my own pace, with my good hiking boots on, and I curious to see where I am going to end up. Music is ephemeral, it is not like a drawing that leaves evidence of its passing. It is temporal and intangible in terms of its materiality – unless I hit the Record button. And then there is evidence, there is a material object that I can revisit and learn from.
At present I do not have a constellation of music making colleagues who stop by or we converge anywhere in particular to play. I am playing and exploring alone. In this effort, I only have myself to hear what I am playing. If I don’t hit the Record button, I have nothing to play with.
So this is what I am going to do to re-calibrate my relationship to recording. I am going to start with baby steps. I am going to use the same techniques I use to train my reactive dog to accept changes in the environment. I am going to hit Record and play one not. That is it. And I am going to listen to that one note. I am going to play along with that one note. And when I have run out of ideas, I am going to record another note. And build from there.
After Georgia O’Keefe graduated from art school she needed to strip away everything she had learned and get back to her own baseline. She disciplined herself to do nothing with colour, to only work in scales of grey through charcoal and pencils. When she had reached her point of saturation with that work, she finally allowed herself to move to colour.
This is how I am going to work with recording. No, I am not recording the viral campfire songs. I am recording my music so I can learn what my music is telling me. Through an evolving process of iteration, my music will let me know what it is that is demanding expression. I have no idea how it is going to turn out. My job is be curious and suspend judgement.
Of course, no recording is going to sound like what I hear in my head. What I hear in my head is the resonance of sound in my skull, my body, my sinus cavities. What I hear from the recording device is sound vibrations translated through electrical impulses. They are not going to sound the same and I am going to learn to live with the difference.